Wednesday 19 February 2014

Final essay.



The following is my final essay for occupational science which I got 38/40 for so it must be alright. It's the final piece in trying to demonstrate some basic occupational therapy concepts to my community. 

“What is a weed?  A plant whose virtues have not yet been discovered.” Ralph Waldo Emerson, (1878).

Over the past year I have learnt a new hobby of making wine from weeds in which I sought to affirm Emerson’s statement. I am now writing this opinion piece to reveal the undiscovered virtues of an occupation, including wellbeing through occupational participation and satisfaction. I will cover my experience of learning a new occupation beginning with an explanation of the process of wine making from weeds and then how I have applied it to a framework I designed with other students, called Te Wharenui of Occupational Participation which explores all the different components necessary for occupational participation. I will also discuss the value and meaning I have found within making wine which I have documented in a blog and make references to the literature on the different concepts. I will also look at how this framework may apply to a service setting which encourages on-going participation in occupation. This service is the Wai-Ora Trust Community Gardens, focusing on the natural environment and food production elements which I found in my own experience of wine making with reference to horticultural therapy. I will conclude with my opinion of how my learnt occupation relates to the services at Wai-Ora Trust and to occupational therapy.

My learnt occupation was making wine from weeds. This involved collecting weeds from my neighbourhood such as elderberry, dandelion, nettle, yarrow and elderflower and following specific recipes to create wine. Elderberries were prepared by smashing two kilograms of berries, mixing with sugar, water, citric acid or lemons, wine yeast and nutrient and left to ferment for four days in a bucket. After the primary ferment it was strained and put into a glass fermentation jar (demijohn) and put under airlock for a month. The wine was then ‘racked’ into another demijohn and left to ferment for another seven months until it was bottled. Dandelion and elderflowers were steeped in sugar solution and followed a similar process of the elderberry. Nettle and yarrow were boiled in the sugar solution and then followed a similar process. Other activities around this occupation included researching for inspiration and recipes, and collection of the specialist equipment either by borrowing from family members or buying from the brewing supplies shop. Collection and preparation of the weeds took from an hour to roughly five hours of pulling dandelion leaves off. Transferring between fermentation vessels or bottling took under an hour with the most time consuming part being sterilisation of equipment.

Two other students and I developed a framework of occupational participation and satisfaction which referred to occupation being similar to a wharenui with many components necessary to hold it together (see appendix A). The different components necessary were motivation leading an individual to an occupation where they began the transition into participating in the occupation. The occupation’s core or tahuhu is to ‘do’ but this can only be held up the pou; ‘be’, ‘become’ and ‘belong’. The maihi and raparapa, the arms and hands represent the necessary skills, tools and resources required. The tekoteko represents the ancestor and historical context of an occupation.  A wharenui would not exist without the whenua/land to rest on and all the outdoor space represents the environment that exists around an occupation. Throughout the wharenui are the concepts of occupational identity and satisfaction, community, culture. There are circumstances however that deviate from the occupation with occupational disruption and deprivation in the marae atea.

Each wharenui component was essential in allowing my occupational participation and satisfaction. Firstly I needed the motivation or volition to choose my topic (Kielhofner, 2008). I drew on my interests in cooking, food preservation, gardening, sustainability, herbal medicine and wine. This led up the path to transition into being a wine-maker. In order to make wine, I first needed to reach with my maihi and raparapa to explore my environment and gather the necessary tools, equipment and knowledge necessary to craft (Collingwood, 1958). As I explored and gleaned I had time to be, to relax and feel in my true nature and further develop my sense of place as I saw my neighbourhood with a new perspective (Rowles, 1991; Wilcock,1998). This transition continued over the year as I became an alchemist of weeds and produced a few brews to testify to my new status (Wilcock, 1998). An unexpected part of my occupational journey was the community I gathered through it (Christiansen & Townsend, 2010). I knew I would be interacting with friends who already brewed but my wine making cut a position for myself to belong in the Blackstar Books collective as I worked in collaboration to provide a brew for this community (Hammell, 2004). This experience increased my self-efficacy in my occupation that I usually perform alone, and while I made a brew with others, we increased our collective efficacy around our views of society, waste culture and how to promote our ideas of wellbeing (Bandura, 1997). The environment was a large component of my occupation and certain presses and affordances which allowed, challenged and stimulated my occupational engagement (Christiansen & Baum, 1997). Restrictions I experienced were time variations and seasonal variations however a freezer afforded me the ability to preserve materials for a time that suited me better. I did not experience any occupational disruption or occupational deprivation and doubt that I would feel a huge sense of grief if I were unable to perform this task (Whiteford, 2010).

The value and meaning that I derived from making wine from weeds was a lot more than I had expected and has become an asset to my identity, resulting in a lot of satisfaction (Christiansen, 1999). When I first chose my occupation, it was just light-hearted decision, I had thought about foraging as my occupation and I noticed that several foragable weeds could be used to make wine, so I thought why not? Many of my friends brewed beer and I thought this was an unique twist on their interests and it gave me a medium to explore the value of many weeds in my local environment. I also thought it would be great to have wine as an end product. 

As the year progressed, perhaps due to my enthusiasm or my curious occupation, I gathered a lot of interest from others who further affirmed my identity as a wine maker. The topic gave a chance for networking and dialogue with others on topics including brewing, sustainability, herbal medicine, the big alcohol industry and capitalism. My networks branched through many demographics, my friends of course were interested but equally were my grandmothers (who I’ve learnt both made wine as was a normal household activity growing up), my student peers at polytechnic and my Maori classes were intrigued, and so were the neighbours where I collected my weeds. My blog, which documents a lot of my personal journey with wine making, became a method to express and detail my experience and a way for my community to see what I was learning, some of the theory behind it.

I also used my wine making skills to participate in the Dunedin Zinefest; a Celebration of DIY Culture, where I made a zine and held a workshop throughout the day about making wine from dumpstered ingredients. This put me in a role of leadership and organisation however I used it as a forum on brewing and exchanged many ideas with my enthusiastic participants. I’m now recognised as the ‘wine-maker’ and will soon donate the product of my workshop to Blackstar Books; which holds a weekly free meal to support a radical thinking community. I am incredibly proud of the wine I have produced; having been in some doubt that it would be palatable let alone enjoyable. I’m already a proud (yet humble!) cook and so this will be another element to add to my hosting abilities. 

I’ve also learnt a lot about herbs and weeds throughout this process which I value highly and brought more understanding of my physical, natural environment. With each brew I researched the properties of my material. When making elderberry wine I also made a cough syrup. Researching yarrow for mead led to me making a poultice to treat a bleeding foot. I already drank nettle tea for anaemia but I didn’t know about food options and made a nettle pizza. After researching dandelion leaves are now found in every salad I make and I plan to make a coffee like drink from the tap root.

Another unpredicted aspect of value and meaning I experienced through winemaking was that of the time I spent with my son gathering materials, preparing them and talking about the different plants and what they are useful for. He keenly warned me of all the hemlock plants as I picked yarrow which look similar. As we went for walks he happily picked dandelions for me.

When considering my occupation’s potential application to a service, I will consider the broader aspects of it of gardening because of the value I found using my natural environment.  Haller and Kramer (2006) provide a framework around horticultural therapy which lists the therapeutic benefits of horticulture as a medium to; encourage human growth, offer restoration, address innate psychological needs, offer versatility, provide meaning and purpose, and interact with others. Related to horticultural therapy is social and therapeutic horticulture which is described by Sempik as “a community of vulnerable people working together on horticultural activities in a garden or allotment, with the aim of providing mutual support and benefit to their health and well-being (p.18, 2010). A service in New Zealand which uses social and therapeutic horticulture is the Wai-Ora Trust in Christchurch (Wai-Ora, n.d.). This charitable trust provides opportunities for participation in horticultural practises as well as cooking and fitness programmes promoting wellbeing. It is open to anyone with support systems for those with disabilities, mental health issues, and general social disadvantages. Aims from Wai-Ora Trust are to teach interpersonal relationship skills and teamwork, gardening skills, provide a natural environment for self-reflection and relaxation and a friendly working environment.

In relation to the framework this service has many of the components of the wharenui. The tahuhu or spine of the projects is on the doing of activities around gardening however this is held up by the ability to be in place and to relax, to learn, acquire new skills and potentially become an employee, and belong to a friendly social community. The raparapa and maihi refer to the physical resources that Wai-Ora Trust supplies. The whenua is the land that the service owns and provides for community gardens but other environments are the social and cultural environments which also hold the wharenui together. The environment will provide challenges such as weather but affordances allow participation such as a service focus on inclusion and support. The service can provide a transition for its users as they gather new occupations. Away from the wharenui in the marae atea is occupational disruption and occupational deprivation. Services users may experience occupation disruption to their ability to garden. The service aims to provide for those who may have experienced occupational deprivation including through lack of employment opportunities, discrimination and environment by providing a supportive, open service with wheelchair access. Within the practise of gardening Wai-Ora Trust provides a setting for individuals and community to experience occupational identity and satisfaction, self-efficacy and collective efficacy culture.

In conclusion I will offer my opinion of the value of wine-making from weeds for myself and then how this relates to others who require facilitated engagement in occupation.

One of the more valuable experiences of making wine for me was the ability to interact with my natural environment and my neighbouring community in order to craft a product. I experienced a strong sense of being during gathering or preparation of materials. This is something that both the literature around horticultural therapy reported and Wai-Ora Trust promoted during interaction with the natural environment. I feel that gardening, or indeed, foraging would be of value for those who need to be facilitated in occupational engagement, as a means to create a connection with their sense of place especially for those transitioning to new place, experiencing an occupational disruption or trying to overcome occupational deprivation. The environment may provide some restrictions such as weather or access issues but adaptations can afford participation, such as a freezer or raised beds. Some press was need because without being challenged I may not have felt so satisfied with my end result.

Another valuable experience of making wine from weeds was the unexpected community I created through it. As I thought of wine making being a solitary occupation I did not expect the interactions I had with community around it, I certainly did not expect to be facilitating a workshop. Gardening within a service such as Wai-Ora Trust could also be a solitary activity but there are also opportunities for social interaction and community which could lead on to many other opportunities such as community meals or even employment. As a community works together it improves its collective efficacy and opportunities.

A potential difference in my experience and that of a setting where engagement in occupation requires facilitation is that of my motivation for engagement. I have the freedom of choice to discover my own means of self-expression which encourages my motivation. However gardening and connection with nature may be of little interest to someone else and engagement will have little value to them. My motivation pulled me through hours of picking nettles and pulling out dandelion petals. If someone lacks motivation or the ability to see future benefits then it may be difficult to engage them in potentially boring and repetitive tasks.

As an occupational therapist works with an individual, the therapist needs to be aware of all the components involved in occupational participation. Starting at the path with motivation into the wharenui of occupation to support an individual in gaining their new occupational identity and satisfaction. An occupational therapist can provide education, adaptation, encouragement, and planning to navigate the potential difficulties than an individual may face when attempting to engage in occupation especially in understanding occupational disruption and overcoming occupational deprivation.

It is through this process of identifying the components of occupation that a simple hobby can be realised for its virtues in occupational participation and satisfaction. Just as I discovered the virtuous plants in my neighbourhood with a delicious glass of weed- wine.



Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. New York: W. H. Freeman
Christensen, C., & Townsend, E. (Eds.), (2010). An Introduction to occupation: the Art and science of Living . Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Christiansen, C. (1999). Defining lives: Occupation as identity: An essay on competence, coherence and the creation of meaning. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 53, 547-558.
Christiansen, C., & Baum, C. (1997). Occupational therapy: Enabling function and well-being. Thorofare, NJ, USA: SLACK
Collingwood, R. G. (1958). The principles of art. New York: Oxford University Press.
Emerson, R. W. (1878). Fortune of the republic. Boston: Houghton, Osgood and Co.
Hammell, K. (2004). Dimensions of meaning in the occupations of daily life. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 71, 5, 296.
Kielhofner, G. (2008). Model of human occupation: Theory and application. Baltimore, MD: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
Rowles, G. (1991). Beyond performance: being in place as a component of occupational therapy. The American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 45(3), 265-270
Whiteford, G. (2010). In Christensen, C. & Townsend, E. (Eds.), An introduction to occupation: The art and science of living . Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

No comments:

Post a Comment